Magistrate of Brussels is an unfinished oil painting or oil sketch by Anthony van Dyck, rediscovered in 2013 after being shown on episodes of the BBC television programme Antiques Roadshow.
| Magistrate of Brussels | |
|---|---|
The restored painting | |
| Artist | Anthony van Dyck |
| Year | Circa 1634 |
| Medium | Oil on canvas |
| Owner | Father Jamie MacLeod |

The work was purchased for £400 from a Nantwich, Cheshire, antiques shop some years previously by Father Jamie MacLeod and hung in the Whaley Hall Ecumenical Retreat House, which he runs, at Whaley Bridge.[1] At one point, it fell from the wall there, smashing a CD player, but sustained no significant damage. The frame was labelled "Sir A van Dyck", but the picture was thought to be a copy.[1] He took the painting to a recording of Antiques Roadshow at Newstead Abbey, Nottinghamshire, in 2012.[1][2]
MacLeod then took it to a second recording, at the Royal Agricultural University, Cirencester.[3] There, it was recognised as potentially a van Dyck by presenter Fiona Bruce,[1] who had been working with art historian Philip Mould on an episode of another BBC programme (Fake or Fortune?), which recently featured works by van Dyck.[4] Mould shared her suspicions and suggested that the work be treated by an expert restorer, in what he described as "the art equivalent of an [archaeological] excavation".[1] The painting was restored by Simon Gillespie, who used solvent to remove layers of overpainting, in a process that took the equivalent of three weeks of full-time work.[1] The removal of later painting returned what had appeared to be a finished portrait into a sketch with unfinished details. The ruff in particular was shown only in outline.[1] The work was then confirmed as van Dyck's by Christopher Brown, a noted authority on the painter.[1]

Mould thought that the painting was probably a preparatory sketch for Van Dyck's 1634 work Magistrates of Brussels, which was destroyed in the Bombardment of Brussels in 1695.[5] Its composition is known from a grisaille sketch, in the Ecole Nationale Superieure des Beaux-Arts in Paris,[6] which van Dyck prepared to show how he planned to lay out the piece.[1] Another three sketches of magistrates' heads for the same work, with the same red background as MacLeod's painting,[1] are known to exist: two in the Ashmolean Museum at Oxford, and a third which was sold to an unknown buyer.[7] A further work, in the Royal Collection, may also be from the same series.[7] Mould pointed out that the pose of the MacLeod portrait matched that of the rightmost individual in the grisaille sketch.[1]
Mould valued the sketch at between £300,000 and £400,000,[1] making it the most valuable painting identified in the 36-year history of the programme.[2] MacLeod announced his intention to sell it, and to use the money to buy church bells, in commemoration of the centenary of the start of the First World War.[1] In May 2014, it was announced that the work would be auctioned at Christie's on 8 July.[8] but it failed to sell on that occasion.[9] It was later sold to a private collector.[10] In 2015, the painting was on loan to the Rubenshuis, and in 2016 it was exhibited at the Frick Collection in New York.[11] As of September 2018, it remained a part of the Rubenshuis exhibition.[10]